Comparison

How to compare nanobubble generators

Most nanobubble quotations are written at different duty points, which makes them look further apart than they are. Here is the framework that puts every supplier on one basis — and what NanoMAR answers to each question.

Nanobubble generators all do the same physical work: shear a gas into water until it breaks into cavities under 200 nm, below which a bubble stops behaving like a bubble — it barely rises, stays suspended for days rather than seconds, and carries a strong negative zeta potential. Because the physics is shared, a purchase is decided by four things instead: whether a supplier states flow and delivered concentration as a pair at your conditions, which generation method the unit uses and what that costs to maintain in your water, where the engineers and spares physically are, and whether you can pilot before you specify a plant. NanoMAR builds five models spanning 2 lpm on a bench to 1 000 m³/h on the S1 membrane platform, combines membrane, venturi and ceramic separation on one platform, and supports European sites from Bergen.

The comparison framework

A list of questions, not a scoreboard. Put the left-hand column to every supplier on your shortlist, including us. The right-hand column is what NanoMAR publishes.

Comparison pointWhat to ask any supplierNanoMAR
CapacityFlow AND delivered concentration together, at your temperature0.3–1 000 m³/h on the S1 platform · 2–50 lpm on the S2 bench unit
Generation methodWhich method by name, and the size distribution it producesMembrane, venturi and ceramic on one platform
Bubble sizeA measured size distribution, not a brochure adjectiveUnder 200 nm by definition; above that it is a microbubble
GasesWhich gases the unit is rated for, and at what purityOxygen, air, ozone
Published resultsWhat is measured, on whose water, and by what method80 %+ suspended-matter removal · 50 %+ turbidity reduction · 40 %+ oxygen-transfer increase
ReferencesNamed sites, or the reason there are noneNone published yet. Founded 2023; pilots run and are published as they complete
Service and sparesWhere the engineers and the spare parts physically sitBergen, Norway — inside the EEA
PriceA quotation broken down line by lineNo list price. Quoted per installation; the variables are published
PilotWhether you can measure before you specifyYes — the S2 at 2–50 lpm and the M Pro at 10–100 m³/h exist for exactly that

We state nothing about any other manufacturer's equipment. Where a cell concerns a supplier other than us, the honest answer is to ask them and read their own material.

Capacity and flow range

Flow rate is the first specification everyone compares and the one that misleads most. A generator has no single capacity: where you land depends on the concentration it must hold. The same NanOxy Pro is rated 18.9 m³/h at 40 mg/L, 37.8 m³/h at 20 mg/L and 75.6 m³/h at 10 mg/L — one unit, three very different duty points. So make every vendor state flow and delivered concentration as a pair. Quotations that look far apart are usually written at different duty points.

The NanoMAR envelope

The S2 lets a laboratory produce repeatable data before anyone specifies a plant. The S1 membrane platform scales from that research work into full industrial service, fed with compressed gas and with no electrical connection at the module. The M Pro is the pilot platform, the Pro the skid-mounted aquaculture unit, and the NanVANN Pro a wastewater unit for TSS and TOC reduction with TAN management. A nanobubble system from NanoMAR is specified against your duty.

Bubble generation method

Equipment in this category does the same physical work: shear a gas into water until it breaks into cavities under 200 nm. Below that threshold a bubble stops behaving like a bubble. It barely rises, so it stays suspended for days to weeks rather than seconds, and it carries a strong negative zeta potential — the charge that lifts contaminants.

Three ways to shear a gas

Membrane. Gas is pushed through a precision pore structure into flowing water, giving the tightest and most repeatable size distribution. The price of that precision is sensitivity: it wants pre-filtered water, and compressed gas.

Venturi. A constriction drops the pressure and the shear breaks gas into the stream. No moving parts, tolerant of dirtier water. The energy is not free: it lives in the pump curve.

Ceramic. Gas passes through a rigid porous element. Where water is abrasive enough to shorten polymer life, ceramic answers it. Elements cost more, and back-pressure climbs as pores load.

No single method suits every water, and a manufacturer built around one method must argue that its method suits yours. Ask any supplier for the method by name and the distribution it produces, and read their own technical material at the source — "nanobubbles" alone says nothing about fouling or service intervals. A great deal of equipment sold under the word in fact produces microbubbles, which behave differently in water, so ask for the measurement. Ours is set out under membrane, venturi and ceramic generation and in the generator guide.

What NanoMAR actually publishes

Published as measured, wording intact. None is combined into a further claim or attached to a named customer.

80 %+
Suspended-matter removal
Lifted by the negative charge the bubbles carry
50 %+
Turbidity reduction
Measured on the treated stream
40 %+
Oxygen-transfer increase
Against coarse-bubble aeration
Zero
Chemicals added
Only oxygen, air or ozone enters the water
Lower
Energy
No percentage is published, so none is quoted

Energy per kg O2

Comparing generators on installed kilowatts is the standard mistake here, and it rewards the wrong machine. Operating cost is governed by energy per kilogram of gas actually transferred into the water. A unit that draws less power while losing much of its gas above the tank costs more to run.

Bubble size decides that split. A coarse diffuser bubble has seconds of contact time and a small interface relative to its volume, so much of the gas leaves unused at the surface. A cavity under 200 nm is effectively neutrally buoyant with an enormous gas–liquid interface, so transfer approaches completion. NanoMAR's published figure is 40 %+ higher oxygen transfer against coarse-bubble aeration. No energy percentage is published, and we will not invent one.

  • Your conditions, not the bench. Efficiency from a clean-water test at standard temperature is not what you will live with. Ask at your temperature and organic load.
  • Price the gas separately. Oxygen bought or generated is usually a larger line than the generator's own draw.
  • One duty point. Restate every vendor's figures at the same concentration before comparing; our oxygen transfer calculator gives that basis.

Where the support sits, and lead time

"Local support" is the easiest line in any brochure and the hardest to verify, so ask for it as a street address rather than a region. NanoMAR sits at Langenesvegen 34, 5258 Blomsterdalen, outside Bergen — road distance from much of Norway's land-based aquaculture, and inside the EEA for equipment, spares and service. A membrane replacement is a courier movement, not a customs event, and a bad summer is reviewed by the people who specified the unit. For a site outside Europe, proximity beats a datasheet line: weigh who can actually reach you.

On lead time, honestly

NanoMAR publishes no delivery times, for the same reason it publishes no prices: the same model leaves on very different schedules depending on what is specified around it. What we can say is which decisions move the date.

  • Gas package. Air needs nothing upstream. Oxygen means a generator, a tank or a contract, and that procurement usually sets the critical path.
  • Control integration. Local control is quicker than handing setpoints to an existing SCADA.

Ask a nanobubble supplier in Europe for specifics and you will get them.

Price transparency

No page on nanomar.no carries a price. That is policy rather than evasion: NanoMAR quotes per installation because the same model lands at very different totals depending on duty. What we will do — and what you should demand of every vendor — is name the variables that move the number.

  • Delivered concentration. The largest lever, and the one most often left out. A unit specified at 40 mg/L moves a fraction of the flow it would at 10 mg/L.
  • Gas supply. Air costs nothing to source; oxygen brings a generator, tank or contract that often outweighs the machine.
  • Separation stage. Membrane, venturi or ceramic. The water chemistry decides, and it carries consumables as well as capital.
  • Retrofit or new build. Interfaces into an existing plant are where budgets are lost.
  • Instrumentation. Monitoring, interlocks and SCADA integration are real line items, and the first to vanish from a cheaper quote.

Each is worked through on our page about what drives a nanobubble generator price. A supplier who will not break a quotation down that way has told you something.

Where NanoMAR is not the answer

A comparison that finds no case against itself is a sales page pretending to be an analysis. These are our own limits, in our own words. If one of them is your binding constraint, buy elsewhere and we will say so on the call.

  • You need published references today. NanoMAR has none yet: founded in 2023, pilots running, results published as they complete. If procurement scores reference installations, that counts against us and there is no way to argue it away.
  • Your site is outside Europe. Engineering, service and spares run from Bergen. For a plant in the Americas or Asia-Pacific, weigh who can physically reach the site in a bad week against a line in a datasheet — ours included.
  • You are buying inside an existing framework agreement. Where a group has already standardised on a supplier, adding a second vendor can cost more in qualification and spares inventory than the technical preference is worth.
  • Your duty falls outside our envelope. Our models cover 2 lpm on the S2 to 1 000 m³/h on the S1 membrane platform. Outside that we would rather say so than stretch a unit past what it is rated for.

Where NanoMAR fits

The mirror image: where the engineering favours what we build.

The water is difficult

Three separation methods on one platform: the stage is chosen for your water, not inherited from a single-method design.

The site is European

Engineering, service and spares run from Bergen, inside the EEA. Same time zone, no intercontinental logistics.

You want to pilot first

The S2 at 2–50 lpm and the M Pro at 10–100 m³/h let a design basis be measured, not assumed.

Continuous aquaculture duty

The NanOxy Pro is skid-mounted for continuous service, quoted against a delivered concentration.

Wastewater, several targets

The NanVANN Pro covers 5–500 m³/h for TSS and TOC reduction with TAN management.

How to decide

A process that works for any shortlist of nanobubble companies, ours included.

  1. 01

    Write the duty point down first

    Flow, target concentration, temperature range, solids and organic load — the worst case, not the average. Every vendor then answers one question instead of their favourite one.

  2. 02

    Make each vendor restate their figures at it

    Not headline capacity, but delivered performance at your conditions with the gas supply you will actually have.

  3. 03

    Cost the whole life

    Energy per kilogram transferred, consumables, element replacement, and what a failure costs you in biomass or discharge consent.

  4. 04

    Pilot on your own water

    Run the trial on the real stream, in the season that worries you. A pilot turns anyone's claim into your own data.

Put the same question to every supplier: at my flow, at my temperature, at my target concentration, what dissolved oxygen will I hold at the far end of the tank? Anyone who answers with a bubble-size claim has not answered it.
Behnood Sjåstad Fathi Co-founder & CTO, NanoMAR — 6+ years on aquaculture water-treatment projects

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare nanobubble generators from different suppliers?

Put every supplier on one duty point before you read a single datasheet. Write down flow, target delivered concentration, temperature range, solids and organic load at your worst case, then require each vendor to state flow and concentration together at those conditions. Capacity quoted without a concentration is not a specification. After that, compare generation method, energy per kilogram of gas transferred rather than installed kilowatts, where the spares physically sit, and whether you can pilot first.

What should a nanobubble supplier tell me before I buy?

Five things, in writing: a measured bubble-size distribution rather than the word "nanobubble"; the generation method by name, with its consumables and service interval; flow and delivered concentration as a pair at your conditions; a quotation broken down by gas package, separation stage, instrumentation and integration; and either named reference sites or a straight explanation of why there are none. NanoMAR answers all five, including that it has no publishable references yet.

Which nanobubble companies should I shortlist?

Judge any nanobubble supplier on four things rather than on reputation: whether they state delivered concentration and flow together at your conditions, which generation method the unit uses and what it costs to maintain in your water, where the engineers and spares physically are relative to your site, and whether you can run a pilot before specifying a plant. A supplier who answers all four plainly belongs on the list, whoever they are.

Does NanoMAR publish prices for its nanobubble generators?

No. NanoMAR publishes no list price and no delivery time, because the same model lands at very different totals depending on delivered concentration, gas supply, separation stage and duty cycle. NanoMAR publishes the variables that move the number instead, so quotations can be compared line by line.

What is the difference between a nanobubble and a microbubble?

Size, and it changes the behaviour completely. A nanobubble is under 200 nm: effectively neutrally buoyant, so it stays suspended for days to weeks, with an enormous gas–liquid interface and a strong negative surface charge. A microbubble is orders of magnitude larger, rises within seconds and bursts at the surface, taking much of its gas with it. A good deal of equipment is sold using the first word while producing the second, which is why a measured size distribution matters more than the label.

Compare us on your own water

Send your flow, your target concentration and what the water is doing today. Our engineers in Bergen will size it, and say plainly if the duty falls outside what we build.

Talk to an engineer

Ready to rethink your water?

Tell us about your process and we'll size a nanobubble system for it.

Talk to our team